home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
-
- The eclectic nature of FUDGIT makes it a borderline program.
- I would like to include the following comments on copyrights.
-
- Some Definitions
- ================
-
- Scientific Community: By "Scientific Community" is meant the whole of
- researchers in industries, universities and government agencies,
- students as well as individuals making research on their own.
-
- Software Developers: By "Software Developers" is meant all the
- people writing or selling softwares with commercial purposes.
-
- Publicly Available Sources: By "Publicly Available Sources" is meant
- the pool of all source codes, algorithms and ideas that can be found
- in publicly available scientific journals, publicly available
- educational books, public domain source code, algorithms and ideas, or
- source code, algorithms and ideas aimed at helping the Scientific
- Community. That is, Publicly Available Sources are publicly available
- material that can be part of higher education programs.
-
- Progressive Copyrights
- ======================
-
- People involved in the Scientific Community need access to the most
- recent developments to continue their own research. At the same time,
- the same people share their most recent discoveries to the rest of the
- Scientific Community. Standard Copyrights apply to the commercial
- applications of their results.
-
- Source code raised the problem that for the first time, the research
- product is deeply involved in the research process. For the first
- time, restrictions are being put on a fundamental research tool. This
- is why the traditional way of thinking about Copyrights is obsolete.
-
- Copyrights were implemented with the idea of protecting the commercial
- interests of the owner. Thus, standard Copyrights give the owner the
- exclusive rights of having commercial applications of his/her
- implementation of an idea. However, some copyrights are much too
- restrictive concerning scientific applications. Sometimes, old ideas
- suddenly become protected because a group of Software Developers
- claim Copyrights for pieces of code that freely existed for a long
- time already, or are the straightforward representation of a given idea
- in a given language. This simply does not make sense, and for this
- reason, more realistic copyright procedures are required.
-
- Progressive Copyrights should give the author the full commercial
- rights but leaves the Scientific Community the right to use the source
- code, the algorithms and the ideas for their own purposes. It does not
- allow Software Developers to use the source code for commercial
- applications, but they are free to use the ideas included in the
- source code. In other words, Software Developers cannot make money
- from the hard work someone else did. If they want to do so, they have
- to agree with the people owning the Progressive Copyrights.
-
- Progressive Copyrights should apply to all Publicly Available Sources.
- From the moment a source code is published and becomes publicly
- available, the people from the whole Scientific Community have the
- right to use it for their own purposes.
-
- A small group of Software Developers cannot claim Copyrights for
- source code, algorithms and ideas that have been around for a while,
- tested, improved, and commented by the whole Scientific Community.
-
- A University student cannot start in life with a Bachelor degree and
- have part of it copyrighted!
-
- Progressive Copyrights are more a way of thinking than a legal
- matter. I just hope that this way of thinking will spread in the
- Scientific Community. After all, Progressive Copyrights are just
- common sense! Despite Software Developers lobby.
-